My topic is 1. e4 c5 2. Nf3 d6 3. d4 cxd4 4. Nxd4 Nf6 5. Nc3 g6 6. Be3 Bg7 7. f3 Nc6 8. Qd2 O-O 9. O-O-O Nxd4 10. Bxd4 Be6 11. Kb1 Qc7 12. h4 Rfc8 13. h5 Qa5 14. hxg6 hxg6 15. a3 15... Bc4 16. Bxc4 Rxc4.
Quote: 17.Qc1 e6 18.g4 Rac8 19.g5 Nh5 20.Bg7: Kg7: 21.Rd6: Rc3: 22.bc3: Ng3 23.Re1 Ne2
..and here I said that I thought that rather than 24. Qb2 as proposed, White should go in for 24. Rxe2 Qb5+ 25. Qb2 Qxe2 26. c4+ Kg8 27. Qc3, saying that it looked pretty bad for Black.
TopNotch proposed 27...Qg2, which I think is probably the best move, and expressed the view that the position is not very testing for Black. I then suggested 28. Rd7 Qxg5 29. Rxb7 Qc5 30. Kb2. In a little conversation that TopNotch and I have been having on another thread, he did concede that the ending appears slightly favorable for White but not as bad as "pretty bad for Black" would seem to imply.
Well, shall we examine this? Since we're down to Q+R and four or five pawns on each side, we may be able to discover Truth here. I confess that I am not a strong enough player to know it just from looking at the position. Once again, I am at work and without sight of the board, but I think that White has pawns a3, c2, c4, e4, f3, king b2, queen c3, rook b7; Black has pawns a7, e6, f7, g6, king g8, Queen c5, rook c8. Objectively, all positions are either won, lost or drawn, so that about this one? Anyone have any opinions, analysis or perhaps condemnations of my whole understanding of chess? (It may be useful to consider, of course, whether all this really is best play after 27. Qc3.)
One obvious question is whether Black can draw the rook and pawn ending after 30...Qxc4 31. Qxc4 Rxc4 32. Rxa7, but to me that looks like it might be difficult. [If no one else cares to contibute, I'll just edit this post to add what more I learn.] For example, last night a student and I looked at 32...f5, but White meets this with 33. Re7 fxe5 34. Rxe6 exf3 (34...Rd6!? occurs to me now) 35. Rf6.
We also decided that White's best reply to 30...a6 appears to be 31. a4 (and not the pointless 31. Qf6).