Tater_Salad wrote on 11/13/05 at 02:05:35:
after playing a few games, i have to stick with my original assessment that 1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Bb5 Nd4 4. Nxd4 exd4 5. O-O Bc5 6. d3 c6 7. Ba4 Ne7 8. f4 isn't nearly as good for white as it may look. i think the problem with a lot of these bird lines is that both engines and humans have the tendency to jump the gun with d5, and i'm not really sure why. i'm not a big praxis guy, but one that i actually abide by almost religiously is not breaking open the middle of the board before castling unless the particular tactics of the position deem it necessary. in these lines, its not as if white has so much going that the immediate c6/d5 is neccessary to push him back. white is still trying to get developed, and those moves will still be there in the meantime.
anyways. after 8....o-o, 9.f4 has been the most common response for me to this point. its pretty hard to develop otherwise, and 9...f6 is blacks best reply, so at least it doesn't waste another move.
Maybe it is time to dig up this thread and state that after 10. f5, according to Greet, White has a strong attack. The question is if the Bishop is out of play, and for that matter, if it matters to White's attack since Black has some pieces out of play.
Some analysis by Sokolov seem to suggest Black is ok in other lines, but I have to say they look very suspicious, with a rook on h7 e.g.
Markovich's idea of playing an early c3 might be White's best option.
Another way is to have the discussion under the Spanish repertoire-thread.