Uberdecker wrote on 09/21/06 at 22:53:58:
Well, it depends on what you mean by "strong". My results are very inconsistant and I can miss mate in one against anybody, but from time to time I get the satisfaction of beating a GM by conducting a strategically rich and complete game, not just thx to some cheap tactic
Thank you for your solicitude, but I am just too stuborn to mend my ways.
Anyway, enough about me. I fully understand Markovitch's irritation at my previous posts. Failing to take into account the erratic aspect of the chess struggle leads to an unrealistic view of things.
But of course, I maintain all comments pertaining specifically to the Garb.
Uberdecker wrote on 09/22/06 at 10:47:58:
Ah, my dear MNb, never miss a chance to step in with your two left feet. As you recognise yourself, you have nothing but clichés to add to this discussion.
I must say that you and TopNotch lack a certain savoir-vivre. I am probably the only regular contributor who provides unprompted insight into his own chess failings, and you find nothing better than to pounce upon the opportunity to patronize and offer common-place advice. Compared to this, tactics are indeed not cheap at all.
Let's drop it shall we? And return, if need be, to the comparison between various lines against the Garb.
Uber......do not expect to toss in an insult and then expect the matter to be dropped.
You opened the door to your failings as you call them, and I tried to help you, I had no idea that you felt insulted by my post or that I was spouting cliches.
Moreover I got the feeling that you were actually proud of your tactical disdain, despite the fact that it is virtually impossible to succeed in chess without proficiency in this area. If this knowledge is cliche, then you would not refer to tactics as cheap tricks, you would understand that a strategic plan can only work if tactical nuances are taken into account.
I would love to see these 'strategic' masterpieces where you manage to outplay grandmasters without having to employ a tactical stroke.
Toppy