"
As to your specific line: Isn't this just the line Vigus is recommending not to play?"
Yes, it is and I was aware of that during the game.
What I wanted to emphasize is that he truly believed an Exchange Slav line with an early ..e6 couldn't possibly be good for Black... (He was shaking his head. And even more so after my ..Nh5. But he didn't know the antidote. I was the one who screwed it up shortly by taking on g3 with the knight prematurely, thus tearing up my kingside for White to attack it.)
The other FM I mentioned had also been around for a while, as a NID player at that, yet he played against me:
1 d4 Nf6 2 Nf3 e6 3. Bg5 c5 4. e3 b6? 5. d5 exd5
(5... Be7 6. Nc3 exd5 7. Nxd5 Bb7 8. Bxf6 Bxf6
9. c3)
6. Nc3 Be7 7. Nxd5 Nxd5? 8. Qxd5
It is only 8 moves and White is already much better. (After a few further moves and mass exchanges it became "+/=" with zero winning chances for Black, and a draw was agreed, but I could have played the "+/-" position more ambitously--for a win.)
This 4..b6? is a classic mistake of Black's. Basic books on the Torre Attack start with it. (And he had been a NID/QID player for decades...)
---
I guess you and Willempie are both FMs.
---
BTW, at the bottom of the previous page, I "hid" a question, in bold blue letters...
Papageno wrote on 07/25/09 at 20:30:42:
Speaking about FMs: most likely a 60+ yrs old FM is not necessarily familiar with the latest theory. He will often just play by general principles etc. Here I definitely agree with Willempie. – As to knowledge of classics this may vary a lot among FMs. There are FMs around who e.g. know every single game of Bobby's 60 memorable games by heart. And others who never have touched that book or have ever heared of that book...
As to your specific line: Isn't this just the line Vigus is recommending not to play? 1. d4 e6 2. Nf3 c5 3. c3 cxd4 4. cxd4 d5 5. Nc3 Nc6 6. Bf4 Nf6 7. e3 Nh5 and then 8. Bg5! see page 197 f. in Vigus' book. However, 8. Be5 is by no means worse in my opinion and in the game Almasi-Erdos, 2005 White has been in the driver's seat for most time. So again I defend the side of the 60+ years old FM and his positional feeling.