Marc Benford wrote on 07/09/15 at 20:52:44:
Hello.
I’m thinking about picking the Nf3 Exchange Slav as my answer to the Slav.
I start with 1. Nf3, so if I choose the Exchange Slav I will need to play the old main line (1. d4 d5 2. c4 c6 3. cxd5 cxd5 4. Nf3 Nf6 5. Nc3 Nc6 6. Bf4 Bf5 7. e3 e6), not the modern main line (1. d4 d5 2. c4 c6 3. cxd5 cxd5 4. Bf4 Nc6 5. e3 Nf6 6. Nc3 Bf5 7. Qb3).
But I’m talking about playing the Nf3 Exchange Slav every single time that Black plays the Slav - it would be my sole and only response to the Slav. And currently I’m 1900 Elo, but I might become as strong as 2200 Elo one day… so could I still play the Nf3 Exchange Slav even against 2200-2400 Elo players?
And I don’t want to play it just to get a draw. I would prefer to win if possible. Though, since I don’t care about getting first place in OTB tournaments and getting some prizes, I will never be in a “must-win situation”, so getting a draw will never be such a bad result.
So why am I thinking about picking the Nf3 Exchange Slav? Because it’s by a very wide margin the most positional, solid, quiet, strategic variation against the Slav. And “positional, solid, quiet, strategic” is exactly my style.
But still, I want some advantage with the White pieces! If the Nf3 Exchange Slav completely gives up White’s first move advantage then I will not choose this opening.
So does the Nf3 Exchange Slav give Black instant equality or does White still have some advantage?
Do you think I should choose the Nf3 Exchange Slav or not? If not, what other opening would you recommend me against the Slav?
Thanks in advance for your answers.
I wouldn't play it in every single game (complement it with something a bit more enterprising, such as the Slow Slav as suggested) but it would be fine as a regular choice - I think Black has to be a little bit accurate to get his equality. You'll probably find you outplay weaker players with it and (if you do your homework) stronger players will deviate with some inferior move to avoid a drawish position. A much stronger player would outplay you in almost any position so that shouldn't really be a factor in your opening choice.
You won't get any advantage, but you also won't be taking any risk, which will probably suit you just perfectly, especially since you seem to care a lot more about being comfortable with the position than how much better you are (which is quite normal and not necessarily bad at the amateur level). If you play it every time as a 2200 player, you'll find weaker players will just prepare the equalising lines and that will get boring for you, hence the suggestion of having something else up your sleeve, maybe even in Flank Openings territory.