brabo wrote on 02/05/19 at 09:19:35:
tipau wrote on 02/05/19 at 08:49:37:
I'm very much looking forward to reading this book. I've found Sadler's previous books very instructive and a joy to read - I'm sure he'll have some very interesting observations about arguably the strongest chess playing entity in existence today.
I liked Sadler's book Chess for Life as I mentioned in the article
https://chess-brabo.blogspot.com/2016/06/peakrating.htmlHowever this book is advertised as it is a must to read if you want to become a stronger player which I believe is nonsense.
tipau wrote on 02/05/19 at 08:49:37:
Clearly it's much harder to explain to Magnus how he can play better chess than is it for a relative patzer like me. I imagine that he wouldn't benefit nearly as much as me from reading other books on chess either. The fact that the book didn't turn him into AlphaZero isn't a negative, but the fact that he was inspired enough to think about it during the game is very interesting.
It reminds me of some of my students rated around 2000 elo and lower which wanted to follow courses aimed for +2400 players from a 2600 player. They were just baffled by the content and couldn't keep their attention in the courses. In the end they didn't like it. I think here it will be the same. The stuff Alpha Zero can teach you will be way above the standard stuff most of the amateurs don't know yet. Besides it is like with the tablebases available today. We have them but no human is able to reproduce them during the game nor even understand them.
Also do you really think that Magnus was serious when he stated that he was thinking how Alpha Zero would approach his position. Maybe for a second yes but I am pretty sure he was just focused on his own calculations. Magnus likes to fool around just check his many streaming videos.
Finally I am sure the book still has interesting content. Seeing some new themes, openingideas are always useful but it is not something which you can't find anywhere else and which will suddenly improve your chessrating with 100 elo. Also his previous book was very easy to read and enjoyable. I think that are already sufficient reasons to buy it but stop pretending it is some holy grail.
100% disagreement here on your main argument.
This information absolutely is a game changer for a wide range of players at a very wide range of skill levels.
And yes, Carlsen was drop-dead serious as a heart attack and so are other GM's I spoke with who have made same claim that they have been in positions and have thought what AZ would be playing//planning in that situation.
I have already significantly changed my own playing style including opening repertoire and middle game planning with highly successful results, all based on studying AZ games. I just put my rating at its all time peak, which is something most people close to 60 years old do not find so easy to do, and I attribute much of it to the change in my play that I decided to make after spending months studying these games.
AZ is an absolute game changer (for those of us willing to change our game).