Glenn Snow wrote on 09/10/20 at 05:08:59:
Quote:In your other line 9.e4 e6 10.Be2 axb5 11.Bxb5 exd5 12.exd5 there is a new Perunovic idea 12. ... Qe8+, staying out of the way of a d5-d6 push. Black also looks fine to me, planning to answer 13.Be3 with 13. ... Ng4.
FM Daniel Barrish recommends this for White in one of his chessable courses. He claims White still has an edge after 13...Ng4 14.Qe2 Nxe3 15.fxe3!? (15.Qxe3 was played in Atalik, S (2537) -Ivanisevic,I (2611) Ruma 2017 analysed on chesspublishing by GM Flear where White appears to have the better of a drawn position.) 15...Bxc3+ 16.bxc3 Bxd5 17.0-0. I put this on Stockfish and it prefers 17...Qe7. It claims a modes + over = but it looks fairly playable for Black to me.
True, that does indeed look playable for Black after 15. ...Qe7!?.
Syzygy wrote on 09/10/20 at 07:52:44:
In your line with 9. Ra3 and 16...Qb6, Stockfish gives 17. Re1!, for instance, 17...Rae8 18. Bf1 Ng4 19. exd5 exd5 20. Rxe8 Rxe8 21. h3 Nge5 22. Nb1! and White's advantage is close to decisive.
The rook on a3 is far from misplaced (in fact, it's now quite active along the third rank), and ...d4 is countered cleanly by Nbd2, which supports f3 and keeps an eye on the weakened c4 square. White's positional play should be quite effective OTB.
Good point. If that is Black's best line, we can consider the whole variation almost refuted.
Perhaps Black should refrain from this Qe7-d6-b6 maneuvre. What about 15. ...h6 (instead of 15. ...Qd6). Both
16.Bh4 g5 17.Bg3 d4 18.e5 Nh5 19.Ne4 Bd5 and
16.Bxf6 Qxf6 17.Rd1 Nb6 18.e5 Qf7 19.Bd3 g5 seem to offer Black some compensation, although I'm not sure whether it's enough.
Of course, there remain some questions; for example the flexible 15.h3!? (instead of direct 15.Bg5) seems annoying, as it's not clear, what Black should do.
Petar Arnaudov wrote on 09/10/20 at 10:29:52:
You should check GM Grigorov's database for Modern Chess
He analyzes the 5.e3 variation in depth.
Thanks for the suggestion. I had a look at the preview, but it's not really what I'm looking for. Firstly, he looks at the line only from a White perspective, thus omitting many (in part very critical) White alternatives. Plus, the line he calls "Black's most challenging move order" looks pretty obviously bad for Black, so that's not really encouraging when you're searching for a solution for black...
So far, we've been focusing on the ...g6 line, and I'm fine with that, but what do you think about Black's alternatives (5. ...e6 or 5. ...axb5)? Are there somewhere improvements for Black, or is 5. ...g6 really Black's only hope?
In general, I'm astonished how critical this 5.e3 line seems to be, seeing that it's comparatively unpopular and unknown.