wolfsblut wrote on 12/07/11 at 19:47:13:
Hi,
yes, I was also a bit surprised about this change....., but it is OK, also the other change from Berlin to Breyer.
But the Semi-Slav? Easy to digest? Not outdate rapidly?
I have no News about this - someone else?
greetings!
wolfsblut
heavypieces wrote on 12/07/11 at 04:23:12:
wolfsblut wrote on 10/05/11 at 17:05:17:
Hi,
i have news about the forthcoming `The Kaufman Repertoire for Black and White ´: It will be there in February 2012 and Kaufman will recommend 1.d4!
(I know that because i just asked NIC)
greetings
wolfsblut
Actually, I'm surprised by the change to 1.d4. I'm a big fan of the original repertoire in 'Chess advantage in black and white', and I thought Kaufman had a well developed philosophy behind his opening choices in that book.
Having said that, I've already pre-ordered my copy of the new book. I hope Kaufman explains just why he's changed his mind about his recommended openings. Advocating 1.d4 instead of 1.e4 is a huge change! I can't help but wonder if an element of his new repertoire might be based on a perception that it will make it more marketable; some said that his repertoire choices in the first book were 'boring' - and perhaps they are to the average club player. But I like the strategic/endgame focus of the exchange Ruy and the Berlin.
I suspect the reason for the change was that he hit a brick wall as to what to do about the Petroff and perhaps more importantly the backbone of his e4 rep, i.e, the Exchange Ruy, has fallen on hard times. I don't think even the Exchange Ruy's biggest advocates play it much anymore (Rozentalis, Kasparov, S not G and even Kinderman, S who was rather optimistic about white's chances some years back has now loss faith in it).
The problems with his old rep continued to multiply, when Ivanchuk virtually busted his main recommendation against the d6 Sicilian, namely the Moscow Bb5+ against the d6 lines, within months of the Book's release (See Delchev - Ivanchuk 2003). It should be mentioned that Gawain Jones recently tried to resurrect the line in his very recent book How to Beat the Sicilain defence [An excellent book overall by the way, at least for otb players] but was only partially successful in my opinion.
The Berlin is still in great shape, but still I think the change to the currently trendy Breyer was an excellent move, as it lacks the boring stigma and the instant endgame that doesn't appeal to everyone, not to mention that these days the Breyer scores very well for Black in practice, and the lines given if OFWATA aka 1.e4 player's bible, are no longer that effective or feared. Time for an updated second edition OFWATA rep.
Not to fear 1.e4 players, theory tends to move in cycles, trends and fashions and I'm sure the pendulum will soon swing back the other way.
Keep the faith.
Tops