Markovich wrote on 07/08/11 at 18:41:33:
It'd be interesting to list all cities with openings or opening variations named after them. A only a few would be American, but I can think of Chicago (defense to the Smith-Morra), Wilkes-Barre (Pennsylvania; another name for the Traxler) and Manhattan (variation of the Queen's Gambit). I am fairly sure that the most represented nation would be Germany, especially if formerly German Polish cities were included.
Von der Lasa once proposed that "Spanish" should be renamed "German Game", but few Germans liked the idea. An article in
Deutsches Wochenschach 1915 nailed it: openings are usually named in other countries, not in the "creative" country itself. That author listed examples, e.g. for "Berlin", which were introduced by Staunton or by Jaenisch, or in France etc. His conclusion was that Germany was by no means underrepresented, and the Ruy should remain what it was.
Look at the "distribution" of variation names from this point of view: The Berlin Pleiades had an advantage, since v. der Lasa wrote the
Handbuch and corresponded with so many: Staunton in London, Kieseritzky in Paris, Van der Linde, Jaenisch, etc. - he even exchanged letters with some Americans. Calling variations after cities, countries, players becomes kind of normal practice when you are an active writer/publisher in steady exchange with others - it is a mutual give and take. Call RL 3...Nf6 after Berlin, so what to do with 3...a6? Was played in London, so... but wait, there is so much chess in London already... OK let's say it is the Morphy Variation.
In the USA there are at least as many active players as in Germany. But the USA is relatively isolated, and so many local novelties will not find their way over the pond. In this respect it is a bit similar to the Soviet Union/Russia. I guess there are thousands of creative players who have their own opening ideas, but they have no "organ" to make these ideas known outside the country. At least nothing of the influence and status like the
Wiener Schachzeitung or the German magazines (in Berlin, Leipzig) or the impressive number of British chess periodicals. -
Edit: I am speaking about the 19th century + early 20th century, of course.
P.S.: The
Dubuque Chess Journal 1875, p. 265, calls 3...a6 in the Ruy Lopez "New Orleans Defence".