Fllg wrote on 08/08/13 at 18:08:34:
TopNotch wrote on 08/08/13 at 16:24:50:
I am curious to what Pert has found to make this line dangerous for Black, and also why he did not offer the interesting 1.d4 Nf6 2.Bg5 Ne4 3.Bf4 d5 4.f3 Nf6 5.e4 as a sharp second option, although admittedly with careful play black is fine there too.
Tops
I find this chapter to be one of the less convincing parts of the book and think Black is fine here against everything Pert suggests.
The reason why 1.d4 Nf6 2.Bg5 Ne4 3.Bf4 d5 4.f3 Nf6 5.e4 isn´t covered is probably the line 5...dxe4 6.Nc3 Nd5! as given by Aveskulov in "Attack with Black". That seems to offer Black an easy game without much trouble.
I agree with you that this is probably the less convincing ( and inspiring!) chapter in the book. I haven`t read all that much in all of the chapters, but still. However, I dont think that Aveskulovs variation from "Attack with black" is the reason why he excluded any variations. Why? Its not even in the bibliography

. And consequently Pert doesnt even mention the move 9...Qb6 in this variation.
TopNotch wrote on 08/08/13 at 16:24:50:
Haven't posted here for awhile, but I do check the forum regularly. I play the line under consideration for black and think that he's ok after:
1.d4 Nf6 2.Bg5 Ne4 3.Bf4 d5 4.e3 c5 5.Bd3 cxd4 (5...Nf6!? is more combative and the choice of Avrukh in Grandmaster Repertoire 11, GM Eric Prie also has important analysis of this line following 6.dxc5 7.Nc6 Bb5 and concludes black is fine) 6.exd4 Nc6 7.Bxe4 dxe4 8.Ne2 Bg4 9.Nbc3 Qa5!? 10.h3 Bh5 11.0-0 Rd8N looks roughly equal to me.
He doesent mention 11...Rd8 either ( thx TopNotch). Only 11...0-0-0. But you indicate this is a novelty, so we may forgive him....? Its my Houdinis top move though, so I wonder...
In the introduction to this chaper he says that he has:
" chosen to look
deeply at just one line involving 3.e3 followed by a plan of Bd3 and Bxe4, as I feel happy about White`s chances of gaining an advantage in these positions and it seem to me to be the best line".
Well, like I said, I cant help but agree with Fllg on this chapter. And its a pity since the other chapters seems both inspiring and a lot of fun.
But maybe the bottom line is that the Trompovsky isnt more than a suprise weapon? One thing seems clear; if a Tromp player starts to meet TopNochs line in every game, then he
soon will stop playing 2.Bg5.
Just my opinion

.
Ben