Alias wrote on 06/01/12 at 08:23:44:
brabo: I haven't bought the Nalimov tablebases. Just knowing that I can find particular positions on the on-line versions is fine for me.
I tried to google translate your blog. It was quite difficult to follow. I haven't played any CC games in a few years but in my own experience the way to use computers hasn't changed so much even though the programs and hardware have changed dramatically. Someone more experienced, like eg Larry Kaufman, probably has a more modern view on using programs than mine.
1) You don't need to buy the Nalimov tablebases to store them on your PC. You can download all of them for free on
http://kirill-kryukov.com/chess/tablebases-online/ 2) There are quite some pros and cons (also partly explained on the above link) to store the tablebases on your own computer.
Big advantage:
- While an engine is calculating, it automatically checks if an analysed position hits a tablebase. This can lead to thousands of automatic tablebasehits in an analysis of a specific endgame. This way you have 100% certainty that the millions of positions an engine is calculating, are automatically checked if a tablebasehit is made. So normally leading to higher quality of analysis which is in correspondence chess especially important.
Big disadvantages:
- You need to store a gigantic amount of data on your pc which can cause some nasty sideeffects.
- I have the impression that the engine seriously slows down by checking the tablebases as it has to continuously swap between memory and disk. So it often takes much more time to go to the same level of depth for an engine.
- If you are quite far from the 6 piececonfigurations, the tablebasehits are quite meaningless as the mainline is cleary something else. Again leading to unusefull consumption of processingpower and time.
My conclusion today is that storing the tablebases aren't necessarily bringing higher quality analysis if time is restricted. For OTB analysis I accept fully the loss of quality in the transition phase to the nalimovdatabases. I am however not sure if I would accept this for correspondencechess as it is often exactly in that phase that the men are separated from the boys.