Regarding Botvinnik-Alekhine1941 our world´s number zero writes in MGP (vol.II, p.123):
"[10...b6?! is] a highly dubios decision. However, as later games showed, White also has a powerful initiative after 10...Nxc3 [...] Apparently the best move is 10...a6".
10...a6 has been played by Karpov, Dreev and other strong players with an equal score.
These days the Semi-Tarrasch is most often reached via the Caro-Kann or the Symmetrical English (1.c4 c5 2.Nf3 Nf6 3.Nc3 Nc6 4.e3 d5).
Via Caro-Kann it´s easier for White to trick Black into the Bc4 lines than into the Bd3 lines. Because White can play Bc4 before d4 in the lines with 2.c4 but obviously not Bd3 before d4. Playing d4 before Bc4/Bd3 gives Black the opportunity to the nimzo-like Bb4 instead of the more passive Be7.
But even the Be7/Bd3 lines (with cd4 ed4 already played) are playable for Black. It´s not very popular today to analyze passive defending lines for Black so all published material (Aagard, Emms) only shows wonderful victories for White. My own observation is that on 2000-2400 level White makes a phantastic 80% score as most often he is the much better prepared player. But on 2400++ level White achieves no more than his usual 52% as Black knows how to defend. White has the initiative but that´s all!
I really like to defend such positions, White´s Pd4 is simply lost
The lines with 6.e4 are a quite different topic, obviously many Black players seem to prefer now lines with Nb8-d7. Even Ivanchuk has played this.
tracke