Quote:Sorry, but this is just not the case. Everyone I saw had trouble with the interface, and there were no problems with batteries/calibration, etc, as the maker had a team of reps at tournament setting everything up
Thanks for your opinion about your experience. My device is very sensitive when I touch the screen, and I have no such problem, but I will see in future tournaments what happens with other players and what are their opinions about that.
Quote:TimS I was not referring to this Personal Manager gimmick but to the elctronic sensory boards Tony was referring to.
As for allowing a different recording system like this Personal Manage thing I think it is prone to cheating - somebody develops thir own version which just happens to pop up the best move as suggested by Fritz
No - we cannot allow it
First of all, talking about electronic sensory boards, of course that is an ideal to play and not bother to write any moves,and for organizers it is easy but the big problem I see, is that it only will be possible when electronic sensory boards are available.
Personal Chess Manager disables all functions when in record mode and it is like an electronic scoresheet and nothing else. Talking about someone developing their own versions is a bit like Alice in wonderland, we are traveling to the fantasy world of our brains and imagination, one can imagine chess clocks that running faster for the opponent and lots of things...
In the sport world, there are one thing called:
certified or approved materials by federations. All materials are tested acording to rules to be declared certified.
Quote:In that case I dont see why anyone cant use his own pda/palmtop (iirc these are banned) with winboard or somesuch on it as long as you keep it in open view.
The problem is that personal pda or palmtop´s are not FIDE certified and are not tested to be aproved by FIDE and for this reason are not allowed to be used in tournaments because no one knows what is inside that machine, but of course can be used in cofee chess

The same happens to chess clocks. FIDE have a list of certified clocks and it is impossible to pretend to use an old historic clock of Capablanca in modern tournaments or my cucu clock of my dinning room
In sports in general, there is one thing called certified materials that were tested according to rules of any sport. For example in tennis tournaments it is not possible to use any kind of racket. Materials have official measures and the same happens to chess pieces or boards.