ErictheRed wrote on 04/18/12 at 15:26:32:
Off topic, but...does anyone here actually get anything from Heisman?!?? Really?? His articles on Chesscafe.com are just a bunch of words, and more words, and more words...I don't get why he's popular. JMHO based on trying to read a few of his articles.
Most of Heisman's writing is aimed at a (much) lower level than mine of yours. I've still found a few of his articles useful for me, like "Breaking down barriers" on training and motiavtion.
Where Heisman is most useful is in spelling out all the things beginners struggle with that strong players know so well they just don't think about it (unconscious competence).
When I look at a positon, I automatically see how many pieces attack and defend a weakness. I know whether either side's king safety is likely to be a factor. I instinctively know that tactics and material almost always trump "tiebreak criteria" like doubled and isolated pawns and other positional niceties. The first things that come to mind after my opponent moves, are "why did he do that?" "What are all the things he's threatening"? I take for granted that the most important thing the move I intend to play can achieve is
to not lose; not allow some unanswerable tactic or threat.
...and so on. I would have a hard time helping a student develop these skills if I'm not even aware of them in myself. So just pointing them out and stressing their importance (and the fact that most beginner's books overlook them and move straight to basic tactics) is an achievement by Heisman!
You can argue that his approach to actually developing these skills is too wordy, that chess is more about seeing and doing than about verbalizing, and so we should just show the beginner lots of actual positions that require these skills to solve. I agree. But in fact Heisman does give loads of ecercises in his books "Back to Basics: Tactics" and "Looking for Trouble", which I use a lot in my work with youngsters.
He also describes the many problems with time management at lower levels ("Never play a bad move quickly"! etc.) very well, and he stresses the value of repetitive tactical exercises for rapid improvement, which I also know from my own improvement journey.